(5 min read)
The European Commission has published its proposal for a Digital Fairness Act, which is intended to promote fair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the offline and digital single market, and has two main purposes. The first is to incorporate the text of the existing Consumer Protection Directive, converting it into a directly applicable Regulation. The second is to introduce new measures to protect consumers online, focusing on tackling “dark patterns”, marketing by social media influencers, unfair personalisation practices and addictive design, particularly the exploitation of consumer vulnerabilities. Read our overview of the proposals.
On 11 November the European Commission published its proposal for a Digital Fairness Act (DFA), which is intended to promote fair business-to-consumer commercial practices in the offline and digital single market. The DFA’s focus is on tackling “dark patterns”, marketing by social media influencers and addictive design, particularly the exploitation of consumer vulnerabilities.
At this stage, the DFA is a Commission proposal, which needs to go through the EU legislative process, including adoption by and negotiation between the Parliament and Council, before it can become law. The DFA is intended to complement and be consistent with the existing EU digital rulebook, including the Digital Services Act (DSA), Digital Markets Act (DMA), AI Act and GDPR, as these are amended by the Digital Omnibus, as well as the proposed EU KIDS Act and upcoming review of the Audiovisual Media Services Directive. See the links below to read our recent articles about some of these other laws and proposals.
The DFA is an EU Regulation, meaning that it will be directly applicable across the EU without the need for local implementation. As well as the proposals discussed below, the DFA also reproduces the substance of the existing Consumer Protection Directive (CPD), to convert it from a Directive, which was implemented differently by EU member states, into a directly applicable Regulation.
The 31 commercial practices listed in Annex I of the DFA, which reproduces Annex I of the CPD, will always be regarded as unfair. These include providing misleading information about a product, its price, the trader or the consumer’s rights, and aggressive commercial practices to pressurise a consumer to enter into a contract. The DFA adds to this list a number of new practices applied in the online sector.
The DFA’s key proposals are:
Dark patterns
Prohibition on dark patterns within the scope of Article 10 of the DFA: online interfaces designed or operated in a manner likely to deceive or manipulate consumers, or distort consumers’ economic behaviour.
Influencer marketing
- Clarification of the rules on disclosure of the commercial intent of communications, plus prohibitions on exploiting minors’ trust and marketing products for which advertising is prohibited.
- Obligation on traders using influencer marketing services to ensure that the influencer complies with the DFA.
Unfair personalisation practices
- Extension of the DSA prohibitions (which apply to providers of online platforms) to other traders, including bans on targeted advertising based on profiling to minors and using special category data when this could cause harm.
- Prohibition of personalised pricing when this could cause harm to minors or vulnerable consumers.
Spending-maximising practices
- Transparency obligations regarding prices expressed in virtual currencies.
- Obligations relating to paid-for variable reward systems (such as loot boxes), including transparency regarding the probability of winning, prohibition of these systems for minors and an option to disable them for all consumers.
- Prohibition of pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms for minors.
Addictive design
Requirement to provide adult consumers with the ability to switch off the following features that are intended to or can reasonably be foreseen to encourage compulsive or excessive use: auto-play and uninterrupted content consumption, notifications not triggered by or directly related to the consumer’s activity, incentivising engagements at regular times or with greater frequency, and encouraging continued use by simulating interpersonal relations. These obligations do not apply to traders subject to the equivalent provisions of the EU KIDS Act, and the Commission has the power to amend the list of features to which the obligations apply.
Event tickets
Transparency obligations, including dynamic pricing and pricing where virtual queue systems are used.
Fairness in contracts
- Obligations relating to automatic contract renewals and conversions from free trials into paid contracts, including customers’ rights to receive reminders and rights of termination or withdrawal.
- Obligation for traders which provide online services after conclusion of a contract to make communication with a human being available, upon the customer’s request.
Automated contracting systems
Obligations on traders making available automated systems that use agentic AI to enable consumers to conclude and perform contracts on the consumers’ behalf to ensure that:
- on their first use of such a system, consumers are required to expressly choose whether they wish to confirm all contracts proposed by the system before being bound, only a certain type of contract, or they do not wish to confirm contracts before being bound by them; and
- such systems contain easily accessible, understandable and effective tools enabling consumers to express and modify their choices.
Direct marketing
Prohibition on unsolicited electronic communications for direct marketing purposes – while this is covered in the existing ePrivacy Directive, a recital to the DFA explains that it is appropriate to integrate it into the EU consumer law framework and remove the reference to fax, which is no longer relevant in B2C relations.
Penalties and enforcement
Obligation on member states to lay down the rules on penalties for breach of the DFA and ensure that consumers harmed by unfair commercial practices have access to proportionate and effective remedies. The power to impose fines is linked to the EU Regulation on cooperation between national authorities responsible for the enforcement of consumer protection laws (new CPC Regulation) and provides that:
- where fines are imposed by member state competent authorities, they are subject to a maximum of 4% of the trader’s annual turnover in the member state(s) concerned; or
- where fines are imposed by the Commission, they are subject to a maximum of 6% of the trader’s worldwide annual turnover.