Recent changes to the written representations appeal procedure make it more important for developers to resolve planning risks before determination of planning applications. For applications submitted on or after 1 April 2026, most refusal appeals default to the expedited Part 1 procedure, while non-determination appeals default to Part 2.
The distinction matters commercially. Part 1 substantially restricts additional evidence and provides no opportunity for a Statement of Case. Part 2 allows a fuller presentation and response but is not an unrestricted opportunity to repair an incomplete application or redesign the scheme.
Those developers implementing targeted application preparation to protect the planning case, development economics and viable fallback options will be best positioned to navigate the new appeal procedure.
Which applications and appeals are affected?
Section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 provides the statutory appeal right, including against refusal and failure to determine within the statutory period or an agreed extension.
For applications submitted on or after 1 April 2026, the principal distinction described in the updated PINS guidance is the appeal trigger, not simply the development’s size:
- Part 1: most appeals whereby an application has been refused usually follow the Part 1 written representations procedure.
- Part 2: any other written representations appeal will default to the Part 2 procedure.
This applies to applications for outline planning permission as well as other applications within the guidance’s scope. However, application categories, transitional provisions and exceptions must be checked for each project; the PINS guide does not cover every single type of planning appeal.
Ultimately, PINS determines the appropriate procedure. It may move an appeal to Part 2, a hearing or an inquiry where it considers that the issues warrant it. Developers cannot assume that requesting an inquiry guarantees one—or removes evidential constraints.
Part 1: the application record does the heavy lifting
A refusal appeal must normally be lodged within six months of the decision-notice date. The initial submission includes the appeal form, all supporting documents (including, where relevant, a completed section 106 agreement or unilateral undertaking) and any application for costs.
Neither the appellant nor the council submits a Statement of Case. The Inspector considers the application material, decision notice, officer report, committee minutes, appeal form and council questionnaire.
The council normally supplies its questionnaire and application documents within five working days of the appeal start date. Interested parties cannot make fresh appeal representations: their application-stage comments are passed to the Inspector. There is normally no further commenting stage, with a site visit generally preceding the decision.
Crucially, appellants cannot ordinarily submit evidence that the council did not previously consider. Limited exceptions include material policy changes, relevant judgments, certain environmental impact assessment circumstances and relevant decisions on other applications or appeals.
A desire to answer a refusal reason is unlikely, by itself, to justify new evidence. This is why the application should be prepared in a manner which comprehensively addresses and targets the anticipated areas of objection and/or reasons for refusal where possible and the development proposals to rebut or mitigate those issues.
Part 2: a fuller case, not a fresh application
The Part 2 process will be adopted for the majority of other appeals, including non-determination appeals and appeals against conditions imposed by the council. The appeal must normally be lodged within six months of expiry of the statutory determination period or agreed extension.
Unlike Part 1, the appellant submits a full Statement of Case alongside the application and supporting documents. This should address the matters likely to become the council’s reasons for opposing permission.
Similar to Part 1, the council supplies its questionnaire and supporting documents within one week of the appeal start date. However, under Part 2 interested parties have five weeks to make representations and any Statement of Case to be submitted by the council is also due by week five. The appellant’s final comments are due by week seven, with no new evidence allowed after that stage.
Part 2 provides greater procedural flexibility because the authority has not formally decided the application and the areas of disagreement may still be developing. Further evidence may be accepted at the Inspector’s discretion.
Nevertheless, the appeal should proceed on the same basis as the application. Non-determination is not a general licence to introduce new technical work or redesign. Its commercial benefit is a fuller opportunity to explain and respond—not permission to defer matters which should have been submitted at the outset.
Resolve objections without sacrificing deliverability
Prudent applicants should identify the credible refusal risks, evidence lead times and commercial consequences early. Seasonal ecology, access, flood risk, infrastructure capacity and mitigation requiring third-party rights deserve particular attention.
The critical questions are:
a) What are the matters that present an unknown expenditure risk that could emerge before determination (e.g. highway mitigation, financial contributions, pre-commencement conditions)?
b) What is the capacity of the business case for the scheme to accommodate these matters?
Consultee responses or objections could therefore trigger joint planning, legal, technical and commercial decisions which should be evaluated on a holistic basis to adopt the optimum strategy to preserve the deliverability of the development. That strategy may be evidential rebuttal, commercially acceptable mitigation and/or a revised application strategy. Where conditions or section 106 obligations are proposed, applicants and their legal advisors should together test their lawfulness and delivery implications.
Applicants should maintain a clear document register, identify superseded material and confirm substantive responses are available to the decision-maker. A report sent but not meaningfully incorporated into the application record may not be able to be relied upon in a Part 1 appeal scenario.
Preserve choices before determination
For applicants, the priorities are clear: build the case before the decision, protect value rather than simply secure permission, and choose your next move early. Resolve critical evidence gaps and consultee objections while the council can still consider your response, and test mitigation and fallback designs against viability, funding and delivery requirements. Before determination, make a conscious decision whether to proceed, amend, seek more time or resubmit.
The commercial objective is a defensible, deliverable scheme—not a permission that undermines the investment case or an appeal strategy that depends on fixing problems later.